The Facebook Prescription

By Arbeena

Fatima, a 28-year-old woman from a rural area in Kashmir, sits nervously in front of her smartphone, her fingers hovering over the screen. She’s been experiencing unusual abdominal pain for weeks but hasn’t visited a doctor. The nearest hospital is miles away, and the thought of discussing her symptoms with the male doctor makes her uncomfortable. With a deep breath, she types her concerns into a popular Facebook group for Kashmiri women, hoping for advice and support from others who might understand her situation.

This scene depicts a complex intersection of healthcare deficiencies, cultural norms, and technological adaptation. Our recent research into the health-related social support sought by Kashmiri women in an online group has unveiled a critical phenomenon in healthcare access and support, shedding light on both the resilience of these communities and the inadequacies in the region’s formal healthcare infrastructure. The healthcare scenario for women in Kashmir is challenging, to say the least. Years of instability have led to an underdeveloped healthcare system, with a severe shortage of facilities, equipment, and trained medical professionals. This scarcity is particularly acute in women’s healthcare. Many areas lack dedicated women’s health clinics, and the number of female healthcare providers is low. As a result, women often find themselves without access to essential services, from routine check-ups to specialized care.

Compounding these infrastructural deficiencies are deeply rooted cultural and societal norms that often limit women’s autonomy in health-related decisions. In many parts of Kashmir, discussing women’s health issues, particularly those related to reproductive health, remains taboo. Women are often expected to prioritize family responsibilities over their own health needs, and the idea of a woman traveling alone to seek medical care can be met with social disapproval. These norms create significant barriers to healthcare access, leaving many women to suffer in silence or seek alternative sources of support and information.

It is within this context that online communities have emerged as a crucial lifeline for Kashmiri women. Our study focused on a Facebook group with over 30,000 members, analyzing the health-related social support that take place in this virtual space. The research findings paint a stark picture of the healthcare gaps these women are navigating:

• Prevalence of Informational Support: A striking 86% of messages in the group were seeking informational support, emphasizing the critical need for accessible health information.
• Women-Specific Health Concerns: The most common health-related topics for which social support was requested were specifically related to women’s health issues- pregnancy, infertility, postpartum care, menstrual issues.

These findings reveal a community that has turned to digital platforms out of necessity, creating a space where women can discuss health concerns openly, seek advice, and offer support to one another. The high prevalence of informational support messages is worth noting. It suggests that there’s a significant knowledge gap when it comes to women’s health issues. This could be due to a lack of comprehensive health education, limited access to healthcare providers, or cultural barriers that prevent open discussions about women’s health. The prevalence of queries about pregnancy, infertility, postpartum care and other issues indicates the significant gaps in maternal healthcare services in the region. Women appear to be seeking information and support online for issues that ideally should be addressed by healthcare professionals. This raises concerns about the accessibility and quality of prenatal, postnatal, and reproductive healthcare services in Kashmir. Moreover, the discussions about menstrual issues and general reproductive health highlight the persistent taboos surrounding women’s health in the region. The online group seems to provide a safe space for women to discuss topics that may be considered too sensitive or embarrassing to broach in their immediate social circles or even with healthcare providers. 

However, the reliance on online support for critical health issues is a double-edged sword. While it provides much-needed support and information, it also raises concerns about the accuracy and completeness of the advice being shared. Misinformation about sensitive health issues like pregnancy or infertility could lead to harmful outcomes. These findings call for urgent action on multiple fronts. There’s a clear need for:

• Improved access to women’s healthcare services, particularly in the areas of reproductive and maternal health; need for more female healthcare providers and better-equipped medical facilities.
• Comprehensive health education programs that address the specific needs and concerns of women in the region.
• Initiatives to break down cultural taboos surrounding women’s health, encouraging more open discussions and timely care-seeking behaviors.
• Development of reliable, easily accessible sources of health information tailored to the needs of Kashmiri women.

Further, these online communities highlight the need for broader societal changes. The fact that women feel more comfortable discussing health issues anonymously online than seeking care in person points to the persistence of taboos and restrictive norms. Addressing these cultural barriers is crucial for improving women’s health outcomes in Kashmir.

As we move forward, it’s essential that stakeholders at all levels –policymakers, healthcare providers, NGOs and others– take action to address the issues highlighted by this research. The women of Kashmir, like Fatima, have demonstrated incredible resilience and ingenuity in the face of significant challenges. Their use of digital platforms to create supportive health communities is interesting, but it should not be seen as a long-term solution to the region’s healthcare deficiencies. Instead, it should serve as a catalyst for meaningful change, inspiring efforts to build a healthcare system that truly meets the needs of all women in Kashmir. As researchers and society at large, we have a responsibility to listen to these women’s stories, understand their challenges, and work towards solutions that respect their experiences and needs. Only by addressing both the infrastructural gaps in healthcare and the societal norms that restrict women’s access to care, can we hope to create a future where no woman has to rely solely on an online forum for her essential health needs.

Note: The full research article is available in the Health Marketing Quarterly journal, published by Taylor & Francis Group. Readers can access it at: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07359683.2024.2346685 

• Arbeena is a doctoral scholar in Mass Communication & Journalism. Her research interest areas include online health communication, online health information seeking, digital media and gender, digital health technologies. She can be reached at [email protected]

Follow this link to join our WhatsApp group: Join Now

MONTHLY	Rs 100
YEARLY	Rs 1000
LIFETIME	Rs 10000

CLICK FOR DETAILS