No Result
View All Result
  • MISSION STATEMENT
  • CONTACT
  • BE PART OF QUALITY JOURNALISM
  • ARCHIVE
Thursday, September 28, 2023
E-Paper
Kashmir Observer
12 °c
Srinagar
  • NEWSLIVE
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB
  • NEWSLIVE
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Observer
No Result
View All Result
Home IN DEPTH INTERVIEW

‘The Anxiety of Muslims Is Fair And Understandable’

by Observer News Service
December 20, 2018
A A
0
SHARES
3
VIEWS

Read Also

Why Doesn’t Right to Information Find a Place in J&K’s e-Services ?

Jaishankar’s UN address

Ayodhya: City of Faith, City of Discord, published by Aleph Book Company is the first comprehensive biography of a sleepy city in northern India, which has been a place of reverence for many faiths for millennia, but has also been a place of violence, bloodshed and ill-will.

Ayodhya lodged itself permanently in the national consciousness with the demolition of the Babri Masjid in 1992. The destruction of the mosque was the climax of the Ram Janmabhoomi movement that has been at the heart of Indian politics for a quarter century since the BJP first campaigned on the promise of building a Ram temple at the site of the mosque.

Author Valay Singh tells the complex story of a city holy to many faiths—Hinduism, Buddhism, Islam and Jainism. Through a comparative analysis of the various versions of the Ramayana in which it features, author goes back almost 3,300 years in time to when Ayodhya is first mentioned. He then traces its history showing its transformation from being an insignificant outpost to a place sought out by kings, fakirs, renouncers and reformers. He looks at the propagation of an aggressive Hindu cultural and religious consciousness in the city that was exacerbated during the period in which the East India Company became a military power in north India in the eighteenth century.

His book seeks to bring together the disparate events and developments after India’s Independence in 1947 that were responsible for launching Ayodhya to centre stage in Indian politics and the political imagination. The book goes deep into the violent years leading up to the demolition of the mosque and its aftermath through which the right wing gained decisive ground in electoral politics.

Valay Singh in an exclusive interview with the Kashmir Observer responded to slew of unanswered questions on the most sensitive topic which has permanently communalized the polity of India.

KO- Muslims in India are deeply anxious that a legal dispute with religious overtones should not be allowed to influence the outcome of the next general elections. Hindu Right Wing  believes it has a lot to gain with a speedy verdict that will, irrespective of its outcome, act as a catalyst for the consolidation of Hindu votes. Your take?

Valay Singh: With the BJP’s own allies speaking out against it, it looks unlikely that the govt will go the ordinance route.  The anxiety of Muslims is fair and understandable, however, despite the recent VHP rallies, it remains unclear if Ayodhya can mobilise Hindus the way it did in the 1990s.  

 KO- There is a perception that the Ayodhya verdict has profound political implications and can even shake the very foundations of India. Do you agree?

Valay Singh: Perhaps that’s why the case has been pending for the last several decades. Muslim parties are ready to accept the Court’s verdict, and so are the Hindu parties. After all it is a land dispute. It is organisations like the VHP (who are not parties to the main title suit) that have made the issue into something much larger and political.

 KO- Do you think a final judicial verdict either way will not bring us a solution and will only exacerbate existing fissures in a multicultural society?

Valay Singh: I am hopeful that the Supreme Court’s verdict, whenever it comes, will pave the way for closure. On the other hand, the verdict alone is not sufficient for creating an atmosphere of harmony. Communal forces work 24 hours a day 365 days in a year, it is time secular-minded people started doing the same.

KO- The absence of historical proof about the existence of Ram Mandir beneath Babri Masjid will count little in what is essentially a matter of faith. More so, when it is also now such a politically lucrative issue.

Valay Singh: It is a land dispute but over time the place has come to be identified as Ram Janambhoomi. Political mileage is going to be extracted in the future as well. I am sure the Court is mindful of all these things and will decide accordingly. 

KO- How did Babur come to build a mosque at Ayodhya. What were the circumstances like at the time?

Valay Singh: Firstly, this is a region which is replete with history. Even before Babur, other dynasties have ruled the region. It is believed that Babur got the mosque constructed because there were inscriptions inside the Babri Masjid that said so. However, some have argued that the inscriptions were installed at a later date, and the mosque was constructed during Aurangzeb’s reign. Others argue that the mosque was built over an existing mosque. In the Baburnama the pages pertaining to his time spent in Awadh are missing and no where else is there a mention of a mosque at Ram Janambhoomi in Ayodhya. There are other Babri masjids in Delhi’s Palam village as well as in Panipat though. 

KO. If historicity of Ram is moot, how did he come to become a central figure in Hindu faith? What were the historical forces that drove it?

Valay Singh: Historicity of Ram worship in Ayodhya is an intriguing subject and more work needs to be done on it. I have dealt with development of Ayodhya as a place of Ram worship in the book, and it essentially mirrors the growth of Vaishnavism in other parts of north India.  

 
 
 

Follow this link to join our WhatsApp group: Join Now

Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.

ACT NOW
MONTHLYRs 100
YEARLYRs 1000
LIFETIMERs 10000

CLICK FOR DETAILS

ADVERTISEMENT
ShareTweetSendShareShareSend
Previous Post

PDP In Dire Straits

Next Post

PSU Bank Officers’ Union To Go On Strike On Friday  

Observer News Service

Observer News Service

Related Posts

Why Doesn’t Right to Information Find a Place in J&K’s e-Services ?
IN DEPTH

Why Doesn’t Right to Information Find a Place in J&K’s e-Services ?

Jaishankar's UN address
EDITORIAL

Jaishankar’s UN address

As Kashmir's Wetlands Shrink Fast Experts Suggest People Oriented Conservation     
SPECIAL REPORT

As Kashmir’s Wetlands Shrink Fast Experts Suggest People Oriented Conservation     

400 People Sitting Across LoC in Pakistan Identified: J&K DGP
TOP STORIES

400 People Sitting Across LoC in Pakistan Identified: J&K DGP

J&K Unemployment Rate Declines to 5.2 Percent
TOP STORIES

J&K Unemployment Rate Declines to 5.2 Percent

Dr Farooq Convenes Oppn Meeting in Jammu
TOP STORIES

Dr Farooq Convenes Oppn Meeting in Jammu

Next Post

PSU Bank Officers' Union To Go On Strike On Friday  

Govt To Infuse Rs 83,000 Cr In PSBs In Next Few Months:Jaitley

Please login to join discussion

Pages

  • ABOUT US
  • ADVERTISE IN KO
  • ARCHIVE
  • BE PART OF QUALITY JOURNALISM
  • CONTACT
  • CONTRIBUTORS
  • INTERNSHIPS AT OBSERVER
  • JOBS@KO
  • KO – Homepage
  • MISSION STATEMENT
  • POLICIES
    • COMMENTING GUIDELINES
    • COOKIE POLICY
    • DISCLAIMER
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS
  • Refund Policy
  • Team

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

No Result
View All Result

FOLLOW US

About Us

The media in Kashmir, comprising a robust English and vernacular press has a particularly unenviable job to do. The problems faced by it are both universal to the conflict situations and unique to the region. Read More

Advertising

For Advertising on various Kashmir Observer platforms
contact

[email protected]
+91-194-2502327; +91-1947969705

© 1997 -2023 | KASHMIR OBSERVER LLP

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB

© 1997 -2023 | KASHMIR OBSERVER LLP