ANKARA Turkey is getting closer to laying blame for the killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi on Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, the brash young leader whose ambitions for a modernized Saudi Arabia have been undermined by his penchant for making enemies at home and abroad.
In a widely anticipated speech on Tuesday timed to coincide with the start of what was to be a major investment forum in Riyadh, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan rejected the kingdoms evolving narratives of Khashoggis killing at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul. Erdogan — who didnt mention the prince at all — then called on his father, King Salman bin Abdulaziz, to bring those responsible to account, no matter their position.
That could be understood as a veiled reference to the 33-year-old royal, who is the real power behind the Saudi throne, according to a Turkish official familiar with Turkeys strategy and demands in the case. Turkey has been pressuring the Saudis to come clean on what really happened at their consulate, rolling out a carefully managed campaign of media leaks that have undermined Saudi versions of the story, while hinting that Turkey knows exactly what happened.
Erdogans ultimate aim is inflicting maximum damage on MBS, which entails either removing him completely or at least reducing his control over foreign policy,” said Amanda Sloat, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institute in Washington and former U.S. State Department official, using the initials widely used to refer to Prince Mohammed. As there are limits to what Turkey can achieve alone, Ankara presumably hopes that Trump and/or the Saudi king will take action.”
Saudi Arabia has most recently said Khashoggi, a prominent critic of the prince, was killed after a discussion at the consulate erupted into a brawl. That account has been questioned by world leaders including President Donald Trump, and the Saudi investment conference was hollowed out after dozens of global business leaders and finance officials canceled.
In his speech to lawmakers in Ankara, Erdogan lavished the 82-year-old King Salman with respect, referring to him as the protector of Islams holiest sites and saying he trusted Salmans sincerity in getting to the bottom of the case. His failure to mention the crown prince, according to a Turkish official, was an indication he doesnt see the 33-year-old as his political equal.
At stake are power dynamics both in Saudi Arabia and in the region. The incident has, in particular, raised new questions about the methods and character of Prince Mohammed, whose ruthless consolidation of power and willingness to project Saudi political and military power on neighbors has won him powerful enemies at home and abroad.
Perhaps none is more formidable and ambitious than Erdogan, who has overseen the regions largest economy for more than 16 years, and has challenged the Saudi royals for the mantle of leader of the Muslim world. Erdogans appeal has made him a hero for Islamic political groups like the Muslim Brotherhood, which are seen by many rulers in the Arab world as their biggest domestic security threats.
So even as he brutally cracked down on political dissent at home, turning Turkey into the worlds leading jailer of journalists, Erdogan has turned his nation into the worlds leading safe haven for Arab dissidents like Khashoggi. That, among other issues such as the Saudi isolation of Qatar and policy with regards to Iran and Israel, has inflamed relations between Turkey and a trio of Arab countries including Saudi, Egypt and the United Arab Emirates.
Khashoggi, a columnist for the Washington Post, went into the Saudi consulate in Istanbul on Oct. 2 to get a certificate necessary for his marriage in Istanbul. In an interview with Bloomberg around that time, Prince Mohammed initially said the journalist left the building unharmed. But that narrative gradually changed, culminating in an official admission of Khashoggis death at the hands of Saudi operatives more than two weeks later.
Through a series of strategic media leaks by anonymous officials, its been said that Turkey has evidence that Khashoggi was tortured and dismembered by Saudi assassins who flew in on private jets. On Tuesday, Erdogan said the team that arrived in Istanbul in three separate airplanes included generals as well.
We have strong indications that this murder wasnt the result of a sudden incident, but rather, was the product of a planned operation, Erdogan told ruling AK Party lawmakers at a meeting at the parliament. All responsible, including people at the very top, should be brought to justice, he said. Blaming the killing on a few security and intelligence” officials will satisfy no one, he said.
The Saudis promised on Tuesday not only to hold culprits accountable, but to take corrective measures, state-run Saudi Press Agency reported, citing a weekly cabinet statement that offered no further details.
The leaks have implied that Turkey possesses recordings that are being used to extract concessions from the deep-pocketed Saudis, while also using them to undermine the kingdoms claim to being a reliable partner for the West.
Calls for Removal
Some influential onetime supporters including Republican U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham are now openly calling for Prince Mohammed to be removed from power. The princes supporters in Saudi Arabia say hes firmly in control.
Much will depend on the approach of Trump, who has begun to waver on his initial inclination to accept the now-discredited Saudi version of events wholesale. On Monday, he dispatched CIA director Gina Haspel to Turkey to assess Turkeys information in the Khashoggi probe. The Turks have privately warned that Washington risks public embarrassment if it is seen under Trump to be attempting to help whitewash the circumstances around Khashoggis death.
Erdogan scoffed at the initial Saudi denials that Khashoggi was killed, and assailed the since-fired Saudi consul-general for trying to deflect suspicion by inviting reporters to the consulate building, where he reportedly opened closet doors to show that the journalist wasnt there.
A cover-up of a savagery like this would be an affront to humanitys conscience, Erdogan said. He asked why the Saudis took days to open the consulates doors to outsiders and where Khashoggis body is.
It shouldnt even cross anyones mind that this matter will be closed without all of these questions being answered,” he said.
Thats one reason why Erdogan may have been treading carefully in his speech, said Sinan Ulgen of EDAM, the Center for Economics and Foreign Policy Studies in Istanbul.
By not opening his cards, Erdogan is accumulating political capital that could help him win Trumps support, he said.
Be Part of Quality Journalism
Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.