‘Black Day’ protests mark demonetisation anniversary in India

New Delhi—Opposition parties in India have called for street protests to mark one year since the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modibanned high denomination banknotes in a stated attempt to target undeclared “black” money and fight corruption.

At least 18 opposition parties, including the Indian National Congress, will mark the anniversary as a “Black Day”, accusing the government of harmingthe country’s economy with its policies.”Demonetisation achieved nothing. Hence, we are observing November 8 as a Black Day,” said Palaniappan Chidambaram, former finance minister of the Congress party, which ruled between 2004 and 2014.

“Demonetisation was illegal. It violated many laws and cases are pending before the Supreme Court,” he told Al Jazeera.Prime Minister Modi personally led the shock move on November 8 last year to outlaw 86 percent of the cash in circulation, making the announcement via a televised address.

The old tenders of 500 ($7.73) and 1,000 rupees ($15.45) became illegal within hours of Modi’s announcement.Indians only had months to exchange the old notes for new ones.

The government expected that a large amount of black money would not make it back, and therefore would be wiped from the system.But the Reserve Bank of India said in August that 99 percent of the estimated $242bn in high-currency bills were returned, leading to questions regarding the efficacy of the exercise.

Chidambaram said that there were suspicions that demonetisation was a device to help people with unaccounted, or black, money to convert it into accounted “white” money.Subhasini Ali, a Politburo member of the Communist Party of India, said the project was a “cruel attack” on the people of this country.The left parties, including Ali’s CPI, have joined the protest.

“This was the most devious, dishonest and anti-people step that any government could have taken,” Ali told reporters. “The day the people fully understand what this note ban was all about, I think there will not be much future for the BJP [Bharatiya Janata Party] any more.”

The ruling party has defended its move, saying the main aims of demonetisation – fighting corruption and “black money” – have been achieved.

“There are many successes of demonetisation,” said Nalin Kohli, spokesperson for the ruling BJP, as he began to list them. “Encouraging people to go cashless, [boosting] tax compliance and simultaneously identifying suspicious accounts and transactions that will enable boost future tax collection while taking action against the guilty.” Chaos and queues

The decision, which was widely criticised by economists and media at home and abroad, caused utter chaos as people spent months lining up to swap old notes for new.As the prime minister asked Indians to be patient, many faced hunger and even death. According to reports, about 100 people, mostly elderly, died of exhaustion while waiting in bank queues across the country.

But in what could be interpreted as continued support for the prime minister, the right-wing ruling party won elections in the politically key state of Uttar Pradesh in March by riding on Modi’s high popularity.

Even as criticism mounts, the defiant premier insists he will not relent in his avowed fight for the poor against the rich.”A few people who faced the heat of demonetisation are still complaining and are planning to observe November 8 [with protests]. The Congress cannot scare me by burning my effigies,” the Indian Prime Minister said on Sunday.

“My fight against corruption will not stop,” he declared as people applauded at an election campaign rally in the northern Himalayan state of Himachal Pradesh.A year later, official data around demonetisation is still sketchy. The central bank says it is still verifying the returned notes.

India’s cash-dependent unorganised sector – which forms more than 80 percent of the economy – suffered badly, leading to factory closures and job losses.President of the National Capital Region Chamber of Commerce and Industry, HP Yadav, says micro and small industries have “suffered a lot” during and after the shock move with most firms downsizing by an average of around 20 percent.

He also argued against forcing digitisation for small businesses – a key government goal.

“One year after this was announced, our view is that a company or an individual must have freedom to choose cash or digital mode of payment. For small businesses in the rural areas, it is practically impossible to make payments digitally, when both power outages and lack of internet connectivity hampers work,” Yadav told Al Jazeera.

Before the government’s planned celebrations, an Indian minister, Jayant Sinha, on Monday described the note ban as “a resounding success”.”When revolutionary changes take place, it takes years, decades, or even centuries before the effect of such transformations can be studied and commented upon,” he wrote in the Indian daily, Mint.

Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.



Observer News Service

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.