Grim message to Kashmir


Nobody in Kashmir  expected the Major Nitin Leetul Gogoi to be taken to task for using a civilian as a human shield during Srinagar by-poll but none in his worst imagination would have thought he would be conferred with a commendation medal for doing so. What was it that made the Army chief General Bipin Rawat give the award despite an ongoing  probe into the incident, both by the Army and the police? The answer to it is the sheer wilfulness of it. The message that it was designed to send to Kashmir is very crude: that we will deal with you in the harshest possible manner and in doing so we won’t be bound by the principles of human rights or the rule of law. Also, that you deserve far worse treatment than meted out by Major Gogoi to the civilian. And ironically, a civilian who was among the miniscule group of people who had defied Hurriyat  and the protesters to vote, thereby daring to side with New Delhi amid an all-out Azadi campaign in Kashmir. But instead of rising to his defence, New Delhi has sanctioned  his torture by its Army.  What is more, despite the facts about Dar being well known,  he is deliberately being projected as a stone pelter to strengthen the argument that  using him as human shield was justified. Not that even being a stone pelter merited this inhuman treatment.

What is more troubling  is that this compulsively hostile approach to Kashmir  is now  not  only confined to India’s ruling political class but has also percolated down to the institutions.  It was following the cue from the defence minister Arun Jaitley and the rising political chorus of support for Major Gogoi that the Army fell in line, ignoring its ongoing inquiry into the human shield controversy to award him for his “bravery”.  This shows  there is a complete identity between the political class and the institutions on the new policy towards Kashmir. And this policy doesn’t even defer to the constitution of the country on the rights of an innocent civilian. And together with this institutional-ruling political class consensus, there is also now a general social sanction for the use of harsh methods in Kashmir which in turn has been enabled by the jingoistic sections of the media. So it is now largely black and white on Kashmir and their hateful propaganda on Kashmir thinly disguised as news.

New Delhi now feels little inclination or need to  nuance its approach to Kashmir or gear its policy towards finding a resolution of the long festering issues underpinning the turmoil in the state. The policy now  is about an out and out suppression of the  protests in the state and use of the means fair and foul to accomplish this task. But if the past three years  of the BJP-led government are anything to go by this policy has only led to a progressive worsening of the state of affairs with little hope for an improvement in near future.  In fact,  the prognosis for the future is even more grim. And after the award to Major Gogoi it seems ridiculous to expect or for that matter even urge the centre to choose political  engagement  with Kashmir over a security centric approach.. One can only hope that the better sense prevails sooner than later.



Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.



Observer News Service

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.