SRINAGAR: Former head of Indias external spy agency RAW believes that the situation in Kashmir was never scarier, not even in the 1990s when militant movement was at its peak.
Asked in an interview by the Indian Express if the ongoing unarmed uprising was going from bad to worse under the current government, former Research and Analysis Wing chief A.S. Dulat said yes.
Yes, the situation is turning worse. Is it worse than in 1990. Because of alienation and the anger of youth, young Kashmiri minds have gone out of control.
There is a sense of hopelessness. They arent afraid to die. Villagers, students and even girls are coming out on the streets. This has never happened in the past, he said.
Mr Dulat served in Srinagar in the 1980s as a special director of the Intelligence Bureau when he supervised the intelligence network there, the paper said. In the PMs Office during the Vajpayee government, he was adviser on Kashmir, work that formed the basis of his book Kashmir: The Vajpayee Years.
Mr Dulat said the armed militancy and the intensity of violence witnessed in 1990 was not there now. There were more guns then Actual militancy was more then but today the situation is scarier. When stone-pelting is done by youths, and girls, its abnormal Today, they are proud of being stone-pelters. They are no longer hiding. Schoolgirls and women are coming out to throw stones. The Kashmir situation has never been so bad, Mr Dulat said.
What does the future hold for Kashmir in the short term?
It doesnt look good . The sad part, frightening part and really scary part of Kashmir is that these boys and girls with stones in their hands dont seem to care what their parents feel. There is so much distrust in Kashmiri families that a father doesnt know what his son is doing and the son doesnt care anymore what his father thinks.
Blaming Modi government for failing to engage disgruntled Kashmiris, Dulat said leaders in New Delhi think talks are not necessary. They think they [Kashmiris] have been pampered a lot. In response to a question if the Indian government was not pampering the Kashmiris because Hindu nationalists in the BJP might not like it, the ex-RAW chief said: Of course. You know that. I dont want to go into it, he was quoted as saying.
Mr Dulat said it was a puzzle why India was hesitant to discuss Kashmir with Pakistan.
I have never understood why India is afraid to talk about Kashmir with Pakistan? They have more explaining to do. I agree (Prime Minister Narendra) Modiji started well. He surprised all of us by going to Pakistan. The snag here is what happened after it. The crux of the whole thing is that Pakistan is not an easy state to engage with.
Indias present stance that talk and terror cant go together was also meaningless vis-à-vis Pakistan. Here things happen at many layers. We have to talk, disregarding incidents here and there. Surely, we need explanations for Uri, Gurdaspur and Pathankot. But I am told the NSAs of both sides are talking even now Dialogue must happen between the foreign secretaries and PMs. Modiji is a master of theatre, so he can make it happen. Nawaz Sharif is also a karigar. In a sense, its an even scale I am sorry to say but its easier to talk to Pakistan than to Kashmiris.
The uprising after the killing of Burhan Wani surprised Pakistan. They returned with a vengeance In the last five years, Pakistan tried its best to unite all factions of Hurriyat. They failed but now they have got together because this Indian government doesnt even look at them.
The Indian government failed to anticipate the consequences from the killing of Wani. Yes, absolutely. Let me say that we have invited Pakistan back into the Valley. By October things had climbed down. Kashmiris hibernate in winter wearing firan and with their kangris. Thats the best time to engage Kashmiris. We didnt.
Cautioning the Indian government against use of its military, Dulat said Army should be kept away from the Valley and all issues should be dealt with by the police and paramilitary forces.
Be Part of Quality Journalism
Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.