Equal in an Unequal world-The Paradox of Islam


As I ambled towards the immigration counter I was directed towards, I overheard a black police officer talking about ‘self discovery’ to his white female colleague. I looked at both the black police officer and his white colleague. And then something strange happened. I, reflexively, began articulating and musing on Islam and paradoxes. I looked at the black police officer in the eye and said , ‘ I know myself through you because you are so different[…] but , in the final analysis, we are all the same. And this is one of the central insights of Islam- in the nature of a paradox. The Holy Quran appeared in front of my eyes; it was surreal and incredulously amazing.

The black police officer seemed taken aback. He lost his equipoise for a second and then immediately gathered himself.

This was a profound even though fleeting experience- a little unsetting too.

I then thought about the saga.

My thoughts got redirected towards the Quran and I vaguely recollected the Divine verses where Allah says that Difference(s) among mankind existed so that people could know each other’. This is neither the accurate translation nor transliteration of the Quranic verse but captures its essence.

I am not a scholar of Islam. Unfortunately, my understanding of my religion is very pedestrian but I do understand or more accurately have begun to understand the philosophy, ideas and ideals that form the bedrock of my faith. What follows then is a lay but intense delineation of my understanding.

One of the fundamental insights of Islam is equality- both temporal and Divine. This premise flows from the essential Unity that defines Islam. Prosaically called monotheism, the ideal and Idea of Unity in Islam is profounder. This idea or cardinal premise of Islam flows from Divine Unity which is reflected in the Unity of the Cosmos and Creation. The world then is a bit of a hologram-reflected the essence of Divine Unity.

In this sense then Creation-mankind-is One. Differences that define the humans–race, ethnicity, color and other related differences-are arbitrary constructs foisted upon people by time, place, location and power. These differences , however, are real-in the sense that they have acquired ‘constancy’ over time and have become path dependent- so much so people believe in these ‘imagined constructs’. This is not to demean or underplay culture, ethnicity or nationalism that flows from these constructs but merely to put a perspective on Islam and its fundamental premises and outlook.

Harking back to the Quranic verse that acknowledges difference but yet views it as a means to know ‘others’, Islam then by enjoining its adherents to not to be fixated on identity and attempting to know others is inherently cosmopolitan. The inherent cosmopolitanism of Islam gives short shrift to what the detractors of the religion call its ‘insularity’ and ‘parochialism’. The paradox is that Islam has retreated into itself and Muslims have either retreated into a shell or lash out. There are profound reasons for ‘ghettoization’ of the Muslim mind. These include the humiliation and coercion employed by the machinery and apparatus of Colonialism and Imperialist marauding across the Muslim world and the post colonial Muslim states’ abysmal condition and their warped relation with the West. The Muslim psyche stands scarred; this has led to a loss of confidence and the idiom of engagement with the world that flows is that of violence. Colonial violence and the depredations of post colonial condition of the Muslim world created a counter cyclical condition of ‘structural violence’ in much of the Muslim world. In the process, the essential message, philosophy and spirit of Islam got lost in the maze of depredation , violence and the inward retreat of Muslims.

Can this condition be remedied?


However, redemption and catharsis lies within Muslims. The first step towards collective and individual redemption would be to understand the essence of Islam and adoption of Islamic principles with temporality and spatiality as the ideas that inform Islam’s engagement with the world. The past should neither be forgotten nor jettisoned; the past is the bedrock of Muslim identity and history but instead of employing the past as a guide for insalubrious action, it should be harnessed to bring about the efflorescence and comprehensive improvement of the Muslim condition. This may mean a synthesis of the material, the here and the now and the spiritual. To repeat, redemption lies within us and we owe this to Islam and humanity.


Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.



Observer News Service

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.