How You Can Help
You can choose any of the subscription options given below and help us keep our and your perspective going.
Subscribers get unhindered access to all our premium content as well as rich archives.
In my constituency in Bareilly I find cows being taken regularly and openly to Rampur to be killed illegally. I have made squads of boys and they started catching the trucks. The cows were given to a local gaushala. This gaushala is on land given by the government and is run by a committee of traders, lawyers and society bigwigs. They are given dona-tions by the local market associations to look after the cows. No one ever checks their work.
One day, I asked the boys to check the health of the cows we had put into the gaushala. They didn't find them. There were some milking cows in a shed. A sweeper told us that the animals were regularly sold to the butchers of Rampur -the people we were saving them from in the first place. There was no doctor, only a few people whose job was to milk the cows and distribute the milk to the traders. The money from the market association went into the pockets of the committee members -as did the thousands of rupees from the cow sale.
These are good Hindus. The ones, who have little mandirs at home, go to the ramlilas and keep the nauratna fasts.
I was furious. I asked the District Magistrate to investigate. No registers of entries were found, slips of sale, registers of food bought, milk taken out, salaries given. The place was filthy.
The DM ordered the committee to be removed and punishment after a formal investigation. They paid the Chief Veteri-nary Officer who in any case would have given them a clean chit as he had never done his duty by going to the gaushala so he said the cows had probably died. Hundreds of them, and only the non milking ones? The committee members approached the local MLA who kept asking for them to be let off as everyone makes mistakes". The DM surrendered and said that the Gaushala committee of Lucknow should take a decision. I had an official brought out. She was fed and sent back and till today has not written a report. These worthies are still there. The selling may have stopped - but now they have found another way to steal money. They simply refuse to take in animals. I will deal with them after the elections.
This is the story of 75% of gaushalas in India.
One of the worst cases is the gaushala in Agra. I have films and photographs of dying cows, their eyes pecked by crows. 500 animals pushed in there. No one makes it beyond a week. The committee has made a marriage house on part of the land and rent it out every day. Huge amounts of noise and filth and the smells of meat emanate from it. The committee pockets the money, takes the milk and the animals die of food, overcrowding and filth. There is a small enclosure for milking cows and the two employees only job is to milk them and deliver the milk to the committee members. Re-peated complaints to the Agra Commissioner, inspections, have all resulted in nothing because the head of the committee is the owner of the largest selling Hindi paper in Uttar Pradesh.
In some cases the gaushala is run by the administration themselves as in Indore and the cows do not last more than 2 days. They are caught by the local municipal employees who drag them by their legs into tractors and throw them into the enclosure where they lie there with broken legs till they die. There is no food or water as the man on the desk pock-ets the amount. The government gaushala in Jaipur during the BJP regime killed 33,000 before the press found out. No one has been penalized till today.
I have received many serious complaints about the Srikrushna Goshala in Jharsuguda, Orissa. The Committee has sold part of the government land for a market complex and pocketed 78 lakhs. Some part has been made into a marriage hall. The cows are not given water and their feed is old. On one day 87 cows died from eating fungus filled chara. Old cows which are supposed to be kept by the gaushala are thrown on to the road or sold to butchers. In 2005 the gaushala was given Rs 8 .7 lakhs for making a cowshed. Till today the gaushala has no sheds and the cows are exposed to sun and rain. From Kutch I have received a detailed list of irregularities on the hundreds of gaushalas dotting Gujarat. These gaushalas are supported by the state government and receive generous grants from Gujaratis all over the world.
Here are some of the points: I enumerate them because the gaushala in your area probably does the same:-
1.The gaushala refuses to take sick and disabled cows or to use an ambulance to rescue these.
2.The gaushala refuses to take buffaloes even though they are exactly the same as cows in giving milk etc. They refuse to take bulls or bullocks.
3.The institution will not keep registers of animals. If they are government aided they increase the number in order to get more grants. If they are unaided, they couldn't be bothered to record their animals.
4. Most sell animals supposedly to villagers but these are really middlemen for butchers .The gaushala people pretend that they do not know where the animal is going No entries are made in any registers about the adopters. Money goes into their pockets.
5.No medical facilities are available. Most gaushalas just have a few attendants. If an animal collapses, it is left there till it dies. Some gaushalas use government vets who come when they have time.
6.No cleaning is done. If the cow dung is sold, it is picked up; otherwise the animals stand in their faeces and urine leading to foot rot.
7.No proper food is given. No one knows how to mix dry hay and green fodder. The gaushala operates on whatever it gets free or least expensive. Thousands of animals die in agony of bloat. Much of the hay is fungused because it is kept for months in unclean godowns. Water is given sparingly and many die of thirst.
8.The gaushala is an overcrowded prison for cows. The cows are kept out in the heat and cold. They die of heat stroke or cold. The sheds are few and used for milking cows only.
9.Most gaushalas convert part of the land given to them into commercial premises and appropriate the money. That is why there is such competition to sit on a gaushala committee.
10.Many companies enter into deals with gaushalas and pretend to contribute vast sums to get the income tax deduction under 80 G or 35 AC. Most of the money is then returned to the donor" with a small amount kept as transaction fee by the gaushala committee. Many institutions set up gaushalas simply to convert their profits and avoid taxes.
11.Gaushala take agricultural land from the government to grow fodder for the cows. This is either not done or it is used for non agricultural purposes
12.Many gaushalas have luxurious marbled living quarters used by the management and as guest houses. They are made out of donations.
13.Many gaushalas take their old cows out supposedly for grazing and then abandon them there. The cows wander into the fields or villages.
When I was minister I made a law that no gaushala was allowed to milk cows. Milking cows would be put with mother-less calves. But the gaushalas in Haryana are all large dairies with milking cows and missing calves- which mean they have been sold to the butchers. There is a Haryana person who goes from gaushala to gaushala and takes money to in-ject old cows with a mix of hormones which he guarantees will make them give milk again. He has a line of customers.
Are there any Hindus left in India?
Maneka Gandhi, politician and environmentalist, writes weekly column Heads and Tails for the Kashmir Observer. She can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org
Be Part of Quality Journalism
Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.