No Result
View All Result
  • MISSION STATEMENT
  • CONTACT
  • BE PART OF QUALITY JOURNALISM
  • ARCHIVE
Monday, September 25, 2023
E-Paper
Kashmir Observer
24 °c
Srinagar
  • NEWSLIVE
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB
  • NEWSLIVE
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Observer
No Result
View All Result
Home NEWS TOP STORIES

In the hot seat, BJP, mimics the Congress. Says Henderson-Brooks report ‘will remain top secret’

by Observer News Service
July 9, 2014
A A
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS

NEW DELHI: In a dramatic about turn, India’s Defence and Finance minister Arun Jaitley asserted in parliament on Tuesday, 8 July that the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) government’s position on the controversial Henderson-Brooks committee report which chronicles the reasons for the Indian army’s crushing defeat at the hands of China in 1962, would be the same as that of the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government.

In a written reply in the Rajya Sabha, Jaitley refused to make the report public. He said the release of the “top secret document” would not be in national interest. The government ruled out the possibility of any information related to the report being released fully or partially.

Australian journalist Neville Maxwell had made portions of the report public in March, triggering a fresh round of debate on India’s worst military defeat and the events that led to it. The BJP had then demanded that the report, authored by Lieutenant General Henderson Brooks and Brigadier PS Bhagat be declassified immediately.

ADVERTISEMENT

Maxwell had written on his website that he was making the report public as he wanted to end his complicity in keeping it a secret. The report was leaked 13 years after the government had appointed a committee under former defence secretary NN Vohra to look into publication of war histories.

In the heat of the election campaign, then BJP spokesman Ravi Shankar Prasad (who is now law minister in the NDA government) had called for declassification of the report whose contents, he had said, the “nation had a right to know.” In a blog post, Arun Jaitley had gone a step further to say that public interest demanded that the top secret document not remain in the government’s vault for an indefinite period of time.

Read Also

First C-295 Aircraft Inducted Into IAF

Political Biography Of Farooq Abdullah Released

He wrote in his blog post: “Any society is entitled to learn from the past mistakes and take remedial action. With the wisdom of hindsight, I am of the opinion that the report’s content could have been made public some decades ago…Was the Himalayan blunder of 1962 in fact a Nehruvian blunder? Are we willing to learn the lessons from 1962?”

However, having occupied the hot seat in the ministry of defence after the BJP’s stunning Lok Sabha victory, Jaitley seems to have changed his spots. 

Observers believe that the reason behind such double-speak could be the advice of the army establishment which wants the Henderson-Brooks report to remain classified. Critics say this does not bode well for the BJP, which often projects itself as hyper-nationalistic and left no opportunity to target the Congress-led UPA for its many failures on the security front, including its toothless counter-terrorism and counter-insurgency measures. The BJP’s doublespeak, they say, exposes its defence of the indefensible.

The Hindustan Times reports that the only war record to have been declassified so far relates to the 1947-48 Kashmir operations. It was published four decades later in 1987.

Hearing an RTI plea on the sinking of INS Khukri during the 1971 India-Pakistan war, the Central Information Commission (CIC) had whacked the government in January 2008 for being obsessed with confidentiality. The defence ministry was asked to outline its declassification policy for releasing information to the public.

The Khukri saga was immortalised after its commanding officer, Capt Mahender Mulla, refused to abandon the ship and remained seated in the captain’s chair till she sank with 18 officers and 178 sailors. Mulla was awarded the Maha Vir Chakra.

Follow this link to join our WhatsApp group: Join Now

Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.

ACT NOW
MONTHLYRs 100
YEARLYRs 1000
LIFETIMERs 10000

CLICK FOR DETAILS

ShareTweetSendShareShareSend
Previous Post

Islamic and Biblical Heritage Under Threat

Next Post

Thief inadvertently exposes BJP MP’s undisclosed wealth

Observer News Service

Observer News Service

Related Posts

First C-295 Aircraft Inducted Into IAF
REGIONAL

First C-295 Aircraft Inducted Into IAF

SC Spurns Plea for Producing Dr Farooq
BOOKS

Political Biography Of Farooq Abdullah Released

Snowfall, Rain Bring Relief To Kashmir After Record High Temperatures
TOP STORIES

Snowfall, Rain Bring Relief To Kashmir After Record High Temperatures

Video: 3rd Party Inspection And Monitoring For Centrally Sponsored Schemes
GALLERIES

Video: 3rd Party Inspection And Monitoring For Centrally Sponsored Schemes

Follow Ideals Of Freedom Fighter Dinkar: LG To Youth
LOCAL

Follow Ideals Of Freedom Fighter Dinkar: LG To Youth

DAK Urges 3 Vaccines To Prevent Triple Virus Threat
HEALTH

DAK Urges 3 Vaccines To Prevent Triple Virus Threat

Next Post

Thief inadvertently exposes BJP MP’s undisclosed wealth

2 killed after row over WhatsApp message

Please login to join discussion

Pages

  • ABOUT US
  • ADVERTISE IN KO
  • ARCHIVE
  • BE PART OF QUALITY JOURNALISM
  • CONTACT
  • CONTRIBUTORS
  • INTERNSHIPS AT OBSERVER
  • JOBS@KO
  • KO – Homepage
  • MISSION STATEMENT
  • POLICIES
    • COMMENTING GUIDELINES
    • COOKIE POLICY
    • DISCLAIMER
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS
  • Refund Policy
  • Team

SEARCH IN ARCHIVE

No Result
View All Result

FOLLOW US

About Us

The media in Kashmir, comprising a robust English and vernacular press has a particularly unenviable job to do. The problems faced by it are both universal to the conflict situations and unique to the region. Read More

Advertising

For Advertising on various Kashmir Observer platforms
contact

[email protected]
+91-194-2502327; +91-1947969705

© 1997 -2023 | KASHMIR OBSERVER LLP

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • TOP STORIES
    • LOCAL
    • CITY
    • REGIONAL
    • WORLD
  • IN DEPTH
    • FEATURE
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • OPINION
      • OPINION
      • EDITORIAL
      • KO ANALYSIS
      • LETTERS TO EDITOR
    • SPECIAL REPORT
    • INTERVIEW
    • REVIEW
      • BOOKS
    • LONGFORM
  • BUSINESS
    • BUSINESS NEWS
    • MARKET
    • ENERGY
    • HORTICULTURE
    • HANDICRAFTS
    • CARS & BIKES
    • STARTUP KASHMIR
  • SPORT
    • FOOTBAL
    • CRICKET
    • ADVENTURE SPORTS
    • GOLF
    • ATHLETICS
    • SKIING
    • OTHER SPORTS
  • MEDIA
  • PEOPLE
  • CULTURE
    • KHYEN CHYEN
    • ARTS
    • CRAFTS
    • FESTIVALS
    • THEATER
    • LANGAUGE
  • TRAVEL
    • HOUSEBOATS
    • HOTELS
    • ANGLING
    • CAMPING
    • DESTINATION FOCUS
  • SOCIETY
    • EDUCATION
    • HEADS & TAILS
    • GENDER
    • YOUTH
    • CHILD WELFARE
  • LITERATURE
    • SHORT STORY
    • BOOKS
    • NARRATIVE
  • CINEMA
    • CINEMA & TV
  • ePAPERS
    • BAZAAR OBSERVER
    • YOUNG KASHMIR
    • MIZRAB

© 1997 -2023 | KASHMIR OBSERVER LLP