Speak At Right, Not Convenient Time


It took twenty three years for Mr. S.M.Yasin, the former Deputy Commissioner of Kupwara to muster courage to dis-bosom some factual details about the Kunan-poshpura mass rape committed by 4-Rajputhana Rifles of Indian army in February 1991.I am least impressed by his revelations & I have reasons to be so.

Let us first have a look at What Mr. Yasin has disclosed. He says that Indian Army gang raped women of twin villages of Kunan & Poshpura located side by side in frontier district of Kupwara. They acted like wild beasts by raping women irrespective of age and marital status. Even pregnant women were not spared. Women were raped in front of their mothers, brothers , Fathers & in-laws. Undoubtedly there can be no more shameful & bestial crime committed by Indian army than this. But the fact of the matter is that we already knew these details from the victims themselves.

However, an important part of Yasin’s revelation, which we did not know till his disclosure the other day, is about his refusal to accept a suggestion from B.G. Verghese, the former Press Council Chairman, to hush up the matter & save the soldiers in “National interest”. Remember, Verghese and another lackey, Vikram Rao were appointed by the Indian army to give it a clean chit in the matter. Upon his refusal, Verghese is reported to have threatened Yasin & his family with dire consequences. Even the then Governor Saxena & special secretary SS Kapur are reported to have adopted a totally shameful & unbecoming attitude in the matter. Expectedly, after his refusal, Mr. Yasin was harassed with frequent transfers.

The facts are fully corroborated by another top official of that time, Mr. Wajahat Habibullah, then Divisional Commissioner of Kashmir. In a recent interview to  Arun Mohan Sukumar published in Indian Express of 27th February 2014, he has accused the then Governor Saxena, of discouraging him to visit the site due to a lot of pressure from then IG BSF A.K.Patel. He has also indicted the Govt., then headed by the same Governor, of excising his report & publishing only a favorable part of it. In his own words, his official position & standing was used by Govt. and its collaborators, as a shield to ward off international outcry against the heinous crime.

A somewhat similar belated disclosure was made by retired Justice Bilal Nazki in the matter of custodial cold blooded murder of human rights defender, Advocate Jaleel Andrabi at the hands of Indian Army Major Avtar Singh. Speaking to Indian express(March 7,2011) soon after his retirement as chief Justice of Orissa High Court, Justice Nazki said “ I feel the J-K High Court has been ineffective in taking the Jaleel Andrabi murder case to its logical conclusion. In 1997, when I was hearing the case, we had set up a Special Investigating Team (SIT) of the J&K Police to probe the murder. I am personally convinced that the SIT’s investigation was best. Major Avtar Singh should have faced trial. Soon after I passed orders in the case, I was transferred to Hyderabad. The High Court didn’t take any interest afterwards. Singh’s case symbolizes what is wrong with Delhi’s approach towards Kashmir.”

What is common in all these belated revelations made by persons who held position of eminence in the past? By keeping facts locked in their bosoms they have allowed the tyrant & barbarous State to continue wear the veil of a “large democracy” committed to secularism & rule of law, which it never was & never is particularly in Kashmir. Had they ripped the mask in time probably subsequent crimes like Pathribal & Machil would not have occurred? Cause of Justice would have been definitely served better, had the spoken at right time instead of convenient time. Their delayed disclosures might have made headlines on the given day but had they spoken in time, they would have made history.

Let us not be afraid of calling spade a spade or feel despair as truth is a defense against all mala-fide actions which principle is enshrined even in Indian laws. Life & death is in the hands of Almighty. When people restrain themselves out of fear, their lives are necessarily diminished. Spielberg, the noted American thinker & Filmmaker with a jewish background on a recent Holocaust memorial day said. ” We must refuse paralysis. Genocide is evil, but I think perhaps the greatest evil is when people who have been spared the horrors permit themselves to despair. The despair of those who should otherwise act is evil’s triumph.”Our top bureaucrats & persons holding eminent positions need to note these words of wisdom. Otherwise they become partners in crime by default.

(The author is a practicing chartered Accountant. E MAIL: [email protected])

Be Part of Quality Journalism

Quality journalism takes a lot of time, money and hard work to produce and despite all the hardships we still do it. Our reporters and editors are working overtime in Kashmir and beyond to cover what you care about, break big stories, and expose injustices that can change lives. Today more people are reading Kashmir Observer than ever, but only a handful are paying while advertising revenues are falling fast.



Observer News Service

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.